OSCAR RACE 2006

commentary by Nathaniel R

 

days until OSCAR NIGHT!

Best Actor in a Supporting Role
ALAN ARKIN in LITTLE MISS SUNSHINE

Final Predictions 4 /5 I missed only Wahlberg assuming that AMPAS would stick with their beloved Jack. I'm glad they chose the better performance.
Readers Choice: Your votes went to Mark Wahlberg primarily but most of the nominees did well
My Ballot 3/5 similar. I can do without Arkin (the least impressive of the four male performances in Sunshine) and Hounsou who is essentially a lead and is given almost nothing to do other than scream and run and is saddled with carrying the "saint" burden of simplistic movies like this one.
Long Story Short: Dreamgirl's Eddie Murphy has the lead but can he keep it?

Alan Arkin
Little Miss Sunshine
Jackie Earle Haley
Little Children
Djimon Hounsou
Blood Diamond
Eddie Murphy
Dreamgirls
Mark Wahlberg
The Departed
54 films
3rd nom / first win!
13 Films
first nomination
21 Films
2nd nom / 0 wins
27 Films & Shrek series
first nomination
18 Films
first nomination
Other Awards:
None
Role: 'Grandpa', addict and amateur dance choreographer
Other Awards:
Several Critics Prizes
Role: Ronnie J. McGorvey, sex offender
Other Awards:
Critics Prizes
& NBR

Role: Solomon Vandy, concerned father on the run
Other Awards:
Golden Globe
Role: James "Thunder" Early, an R&B star with a drug addiction
Other Awards:
Critics Prizes

Role: Dignam, foul-mouthed determined Boston cop
How'd They Get Nominated?
35% The Role: that grumpy old man shtick never gets old for audiences. This one has fresh spin
20% Little Miss Sunshine: easy to love and well campaigned
20% Performance. Everyone holds their own in the ensemble
17% Terrific chemistry with Abigail Breslin
7% Longevity breeds respect
3% Bait! Oscar loves a drug addict
46% The Performance: brave, memorable and the critics came out in loud support
42% “Comeback” campaign angle, AMPAS loves those stories. Memories of “Moocher” and “Kelly Leak” don't hurt
10% Kate Winslet’s high profile in the correlative Best Actress race.
2% The Role. Could've been a drawback but he makes it work
38% Performance -an excess of bait: tears & histrionic screaming
31% The Role: He's stuck in these fantasy 'noble innocent' roles but AMPAS loves 'em
18% Timing. Peaking as ballots went out
4% Busy -will star in anything. Probably knows everyone
4% Hotness
2% Likeability
2% Still making it up to him for Amistad?
1% Leonardo DiCaprio
75% Performance and Role: When you’re a huge star and you're cast in a magically appropriate role it can equal kudos, box office and even Oscar magic
10% “Comeback” Never went away but critical rep restored
9% “Jimmy got --Jimmy got --Jimmy got soul” Really fun frequent song & dance numbers
5% Dreamgirls hype
1% Bait! Drug addict
43% Performance: Always watchable but even more energized in supporting roles
32% The Role --or rather The Dialogue. Memorable, hilarious. “Maybe. Maybe Not. Maybe F*** Yourself”
12% standout in amazing ensemble and well liked film
10% Career trajectory. Fun to root for
3% Boogie Nights, Three Kings, I Heart Huckabees
Should Win / Will Win
Should Win: Haley, Murphy, and Wahlberg are all on my ballot but my actual vote would go to Mark Wahlberg

Will Win:
It's tough to say. I'm guessing that it's a race between the drug addicts: It'll go to either Alan Arkin (the beloved veteran vote --plus the Little Miss Sunshine constituency) or Eddie Murphy (the angry snubbed Dreamgirls voting block and those that love their big movie stars to have Oscars ). Murphy is the frontrunner and though I initially thought that Arkin would pull off the upset I think that buzz didn't shift soon enough and Mark Wahlberg is also pulling some "not Murphy" votes preventing Arkin from pulling ahead. At any rate I think it will be very very close and none of the three would surprise me as winners. Edited to add: God damnit. I had this right for weeks and then changed back to Murphhy at the last minute. Arkin emerged triumphant
How'd I Do On My Predictions?
4/5 for a strong 80% score. This was a difficult race to guess. We saw a rare case of each precursor going their own way which led to nine or so candidates with a real shot at shortlisting.
Who Got Robbed?
Given the relatively wide open race in this category one could argue that several people were snubbed, especially such luminaries as Brad Pitt (Babel), Jack Nicholson (The Departed) and Ben Affleck (Hollywoodland) who had all received precursor support from various organizations. But none of them are great losses for those particular performances. To me the strangest omission all season was the work of Steve Carell in Little Miss Sunshine. See my ballot for the reasons why...
Factoids / Trivias / Did You Knows?
ARKIN
72 years -old
*
He also directs and is a musician
*
His previous nominations came in the leading actor category in the 60s: The Russians Are Coming! The Russians Are Coming! and The Heart is a Lonely Hunter
HALEY
45 years-old
*
The shortest nominee @ 5' 5 & 1/2"
*
Got the part due to impressing Kate Winslet (presumably the director, too) he also co-starred with her in All the Kings Men
*
Got famous for young roles in The Bad News Bears and Oscar nominee Breaking Away but his career shifted to TV guest spots
HOUNSOU
42 years-old
*
The tallest nominee @ 6'2"
*
Started as a model. Discovered by Thierry Mugler
*
One of only five African-born people to receive Oscar noms (after Ted Moore, Basil Rathbone, Cecil Kellaway, and Charlize Theron)
*
His middle name is "Gaston"
MURPHY
45 years-old
*
5th (?) SNL regular to win an Oscar nomination (after Dan Aykroyd, Joan Cusack, Bill Murray and Robert Downey Jr)
WAHLBERG
35 years-old.
Second shortest nominee @ 5'7"
*
Has two kids
*
Like Hounsou, his muscled physique helped him get famous
*
 

 

 

LAST YEAR'S RACE