OSCAR RACE 2007

commentary by Nathaniel R

days since OSCAR NIGHT!

 

Oscar February 24th, 2008

Previous Articles
I Survived Live Blogging the Oscars

Part 1
-Arrivals / Part 2 -First Half of Show/ Part 3 -Second Half

My Final Predictions
I knew No Country would kill. 100% correct in the big eight categories
Symposium -Talking 'bout the Nominations
With six fine film writers and special guests

 

"Oscar Hangover"

It began with a hangover. Don't judge. Last night was Oscar night, who didn't have one too many? Something had to keep me going through the most conservative fashion show I can recall ever seeing on Hollywood's High Holy Night. The theme was either 'risk free" or they were all wearing black in mourning for Heath Ledger. But if so, I think it a poor tribute. He would have liked a spot of color. I mean, you saw the socks he wore to the Berlin Festival last year, right? You saw Michelle Williams dress on Brokeback night. This was not a conservative star and color is good. So, I frantically typed for 5 hours straight. What's wrong with me? I can't win an award for doing this. No shiny gold men for me. Why these enormous tasks I set myself? The hangover proved short lived and I trotted off to the other job... running a little late due to things like ironing, trying to find my keys, obsessing about the color of Tilda Swinton's eyes; you know ...daily routines.

 

READ THE REST ...
.... ............OSCAR THE MORNING AFTER



 

WINNERS
bolded in red

PIC

No Country For Old Men

(Miramax)


Atonement

(Focus Features)

Juno
(Fox Searchlight)
Michael Clayton

(Warner Bros)
There Will Be Blood
(Par. / Miramax)

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

DIR

Coen Bros

No Country For


Anderson

There Will Be Blood
Gilroy
Michael Clayton

Reitman
Juno

Schnabel
Diving Bell and Butterfly

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

ACTOR

Day-Lewis
There Will Be Blood

Clooney
Michael Clayton
Depp
Sweeney Todd

Lee Jones
In The Valley Of Elah
Mortenson
Eastern Promises

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

ACTRESS

Cotillard
La Vie En Rose


Blanchett
Elizabeth Deux
Christie
Away From Her
Linney
The Savages
Page
Juno

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

post ceremony
In the end I was right to assume that Cotillard fever had gripped the Academy as it had the internet. The love affair with young and pretty women looking frumpy or aged for the camera and the biopic genre itself are both far from ending. 70% of the past 10 years of Best Actress have gone to actresses who recreated real life women.

pre ceremony
It seems clear that four fine nominated pictures won't be able to stop what's coming. Beer No Country For Old Men is what's coming. Even more locked than the picture itself, which could theoretically be toppled by something like Juno if enough tastemakers have abandoned the Coen killing machine for Anderson's messier genius, is the directing Oscar. Braver (more foolish?) souls will predict Julian Schnabel's Diving Bell to surprise but I think the Coens are locked up. Schnabel would be more of a dark horse threat if his film were nominated.

As for actor and actress... Day-Lewis is unbeatable. But sadly, Christie isn't. For reasons that are unclear to me most pundits have been acting like she's swept. But Cotillard also took critical honors, also won a Globe, and just recently won the BAFTA. This has never been a coronation for Christie but a battle. And I looked over my initial predictions and realized that all four of my predicted acting winners were actually my favorites. So somethings got to give (you can't always get what you want) and Cotillard's Piaf plays right into the Academy wheelhouse in every way (beyond the foreign language). All of the most beloved/rewarded Oscar Bait elements are present (de-glamming, playing a famous person, mimicry, drug abuse, crying, screaming, biopic genre, etcetera) and she's the right age. Helen Mirren's Queen aside, Oscar generally isn't kind to older beauties in this category. And to top it all off Cotillard's fans are rabid. That can help even if it is a little unnerving for non-believers.

SUPP. ACTOR

Bardem
No Country for Old Men

Affleck
...Jesse James

Holbrook
Into theWild
Hoffman

Charlie Wilson War

Wilkinson
Michael Clayton

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
5/5

SUPP. ACTRESS

Swinton
Michael Clayton

Blanchett
I’m Not There
Dee
American Gangster
Ronan
Atonement
Ryan

Gone Baby Gone

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
5/5

ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY

Juno

Lars and Real Girl
Michael Clayton
Ratatouille
The Savages

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

ADAPTED SCREENPLAY

No Country For Old Men

Atonement
Away From Her
Diving Bell and...
There Will Be Blood

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

post ceremony
I'm not dumb enough to assume that AMPAS voted for Tilda Swinton because she's a genius or that she won by a landslide (as she should have). But I'm happy that they tripped and fell on her in order to honor a film that so many people loved. I know there are those that think Michael Clayton is hopelessly middlebrow but for me it represents a great step backwards... and by that I mean forwards. It's nice to see a studio film about and by and for adults and whatever it's shortcomings, and one that recalls 70s pictures, too? I'm so there. So... Swinton: a completely deserving win and my favorite of the night. In heaven Derek Jarman is smiling. Even if he thinks the Oscars are a joke.

The other awards also went as I expected.

pre ceremony

It's a given that Bardem and the Juno screenplay will win so there's no point in discussing it or pretending there are any rivals for the statue. But Supporting Actress and Screenplay are more confusing.

Adapted Screenplay seems like a cinch for No Country (and though the award doesn't go to the original author of the based-on material, it'll still feel to voters like they're honoring one of the world's greatest novelists Cormac McCarthy) but then... the adapted screenplay category can hold upsets (think of that Gods and Monsters shock triumph in 1998) and would they really give the Coen Bros FOUR Oscars (pic/editing/dir/screenplay)? I'm predicting the screenplay win but an upset by Diving Bell and Butterfly wouldn't totally shock me.

Whichever way Supporting Actress goes, by far the most confusing of the big eight categories, no one should claim surprise. The precursors could never agree. That's always a welcome and fun development, as it keeps a competition competitive if you'll forgive the redundancy. I'm guessing Swinton not because I love the performance most (but I do by a lot), but because Michael Clayton needs to win something and in a competitive field, why wouldn't a picture that needs a win give her a boost? That said I think Ruby Dee is just as likely but you have to choose someone to guess with.

In tight races like this one, I always long for a tie --just so that Barbra Streisand and Katharine Hepburn don't hold that particular record all to themselves for all eternity.

Cinematography


There Will Be

Elswit

Assassination
Deakins
Atonement

McGarvey
Diving Bell...
Kaminsky
No Country...
Deakins

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
5/5

Art Direction

Sweeney Todd
Ferrerri

American Gangster
...
There Will Be...
Fisk
Atonement

Greenwood
Golden Compass
Gassner

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

Costume Design

Golden Age
Byrne

Across the Universe
Wolsky
Atonement

Durran
Sweeney Todd
Atwood
La Vie En Rose

Allen

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

Editing

Bourne Ultim...
Rouse

Into the Wild
Cassidy
No Country
"Jaynes"
Diving Bell and
Welfling
There Will Be
Riegel & Tichenor

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
3/5

post ceremony
I went half and half here. I really didn't see the overall support that would bring an Oscar to either Sweeney Todd or The Golden Age. I'm still a little surprised actually that Atonement's already iconic green dress wasn't enough to cinch the category. But I did see the other two prizes coming and though I love Roger Deakins, he should have won long ago... And Elswit is more than worthy. He's actually being honored at the right time in his career.

pre ceremony
The cinematography Oscar has long eluded Roger Deakins (No Country AND Jesse James) and with a best picture frontrunner he could easily win. But I'm going to guess that Robert Elswit (TWWB) edges him out. If the voters are really pissed that Diving Bell didn't make Best Picture I could even see them giving yet another Oscar to Janusz Kaminsky, too. That category is probably the nights best in terms of across-the-board quality.

I'm rooting for Jack Fisk to pull off the win in Art Direction for There Will Be Blood but I'm not at all certain he will since he's up against showier (Sweeney Todd) and prettier (Atonement). We'll see. I'm crossing my fingers.

Costume Design seems an easy get for Atonement. The green dress seals the deal and they've probably rewarded Atwood (Sweeney Todd) enough in the past. Editing is where I'm guessing they'll draw the line at four statues being too many for the Coen Bros to carry home personally. Let's say Bourne Ultimatum there.

SCORE

Atonement
Marianelli

3:10 to Yuma
Beltrami
The Kite Runner
Iglesias

Michael Clayton

Howard
Ratatouille
Giacchino

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
3/5

FOREIGN

Counterfeiters
Austria

Mongol
Kazakhstan
Katyn
Poland
Beaufort
Israel
12
Russia

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
3/5

SOUND MIXING

Bourne Ultimatum

3:10 to Yuma
Ratatouille
No Country For
Transformers

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
2/5

SONG

"Falling Slowly"
Once

"So Close"
Enchanted
"That's How You Know"
Enchanted
"Happy Working Song"
"Raise It Up"
August Rush

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
2/5

post ceremony
The big news here is that the sound mixing team Greg P Russell and Kevin O'Connell remain the Susan Lucci's of Oscar. Oscar doesn't like giant f'ing robots. Sorry guys. In other news: Oscar finally chose a Best Song that can sit pretty throughout Oscar history. Well done.

pre ceremony
Atonement
's typewriter infused score is too memorable to pass up I think. And Counterfeiters has maintained foreign buzz well. If there's any justice in the world, "Falling Slowly" is a lock to win best song for the otherwise shunned Once (which deserved much better as one of the year's very best) but the Academy has proved tone deaf before.

Sound Mixing is improbably a very exciting race. The sound team of the Transformers (Russell and O'Connell) have been up a bajillion times and always lost. Did the media coverage (far more than usual for the sound race) finally convince Oscar to give them a career tribute? My guess is it could go any which of three ways: Bourne Ultimatum, Transformers, or No Country. I'm going to guess that the drought will finally end (just barely) for the Susan Lucci of the Oscars.

VISUAL fx


Golden Compass Pirates: At Worlds
Transformers

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
2/3

MAKEUP

La Vie En Rose
Norbit
Pirates: At Worlds

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
1/3

SOUND fx EDITING

Bourne Ultimatum
Ratatouille
No Country For...
There Will Be
Transformers

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/5

ANIMATED

Ratatouille
Persepolis
Surf's Up

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
2/3

post ceremony
The night's biggest shock has to be the visual effects win for The Golden Compass. It's the first time I can recall when a flop has won this prize. It was my favorite of the nominees --though not the best of the year (that'd be the unnominated Sunshine) so good show. I'm also thrilled to finally see an actor's physical transformation (La Vie En Rose) rewarded here rather than passed off as the actor's accomplishment. That isn't common. Usually they just reward the actor. In this case they did both but you can't win them all. Or, uh, in this case you can. ;)

pre ceremony
Giant F***ing Robots can't lose in visual effects. Piaf can't lose in makeup (can she? I guess it's a shock that La Vie En Rose was nominated to begin with since the academy usually likes to pretend that beautiful actress transforming their hairlines and skin tone and everything is the power of the actress herself), and the rat can't lose in the cartoon race. The only toss up here is the other sound category. I'm guessing Bourne Ultimatum just because I doubting that No Country will hold sweeping power love from enough AMPAS members.

Animated Short

Peter & The Wolf

I Met the Walrus
Madame TutliPutli
Even Pigeons Go To Heaven
My Love

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
did not predict

Live Action Short

Le Mozart des Pickpockets (The Mozart of Pickpockets)

At Night
Il Supplente (The Substitute)
Tanghi Argentini
The Tonto Woman

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
did not predict

Doc Short

Freeheld

La Corona
Salim Baba
Sari's Mother

prediction:
correct

accuracy of my nom predictions:
4/4 (but I had five guesses since they sometimes go for 5)

Documentary Feature

Taxi to the Dark Side

No End in Sight
Operation: Home...
Sicko
War/Dance

prediction:
OOPS

accuracy of my nom predictions:
3/5

post ceremony
win predix stats -major (top 8 categories) 8/8 correct 100%
win predix stats -most categories that people predict -16/20
win predix stats -all stats --even shorts and docs - 17/24

see you next year. Or tomorrow if you like to talk about movies all year round.


pre ceremony
nom' predix stats -majors (top 8 categories) ~ 34/40 correct
nom' predix stats -all categories: 76 /103 correct
perfect nom' predix score! supporting actors and actresses and best cinematography
lousy nom' predix guesswork makeup, original song, sound mixing

And that's the end! (your thoughts welcome @ the blog)

May all of your favorites win on Oscar night... unless your favorite is not Julie Christie! Peace,

Nathaniel

 

previously
Golden Globe winners and blog discussion
new my top ten list and the film bitch awards have begun
"IT'S A GUSHER" -the year in review
new podcast (Marisa Tomei & SAG Nomination Discussion)
worst of the year & golden globes

 



OSCAR
Predictions

Picture
/ Dir
Actor
/ Actress
Supp Actor
Supp Actress
FOREIGN
Screenplays
Costumes
Animated
Tech1
/Tech 2


FiLM BiTCH
2007 NEW

previous years are down for maintenance